Unprovoked or Provoked?

Reidar Kaarboe
Hva Mener Partiene

This is not a conversation with a journalist or a politician - because such a conversation would never take place in Norway. This is a conversation with Gemini, an AI, which I began when I thought of writing a short op-ed for Klassekampen in which I wanted to call for objective arguments for the view that the war in Ukraine was provoked by the US and NATO. So I wanted to test the AI ​​- and it became a conversation that now is published here in its entirety.

My questions and comments are in bold italic large font like this, AI's answers are in normal text, and AI's headlines are in bold normal text.

                                             ♠ ♠ ♠

Are there any arguments that suggest that Russia's war in Ukraine was provoked by the US and NATO? This question has never been posed in Norway, but I think it really is an important one to ask: do such arguments exist or not? Perhaps you have some that you can list briefly?

It is true that this perspective rarely dominates in Norwegian mainstream media, but it is a central part of the international security policy debate – especially within the realist tradition in political science.

Here is a brief summary of the most common arguments making the case for the US and NATO having helped provoke the conflict:

1. NATO expansion eastwards

This is the most important point. From the Russian perspective (and from academics such as John Mearsheimer), it is argued that NATO has broken informal promises made in 1990 not to expand "one inch" eastwards. When countries such as Poland, the Baltic countries [joined NATO], and later the desire to include Ukraine and Georgia followed, this was seen as an existential threat in Moscow.

The argument: No great power would accept a hostile military alliance moving right up to their most important border (often compared to how the US reacted during the Cuban Missile Crisis).


Health topic page on womens health Womens health our team of physicians Womens health breast cancer lumps heart disease Womens health information covers breast Cancer heart pregnancy womens cosmetic concerns Sexual health and mature women related conditions Facts on womens health female anatomy Womens general health and wellness The female reproductive system female hormones Diseases more common in women The mature woman post menopause Womens health dedicated to the best healthcare
buy viagra online